Categorized | Opinion, Politics

The Emperor is Naked! A Politician Has Lied!

The Emperor is Naked!  A Politician Has Lied!

Of all people, Newt Gingrich exposes infotainment-orientation of mainstream media

 

Guest Column
By Mitch Trachtenberg

 

It’s finally happened.  An American politician has finally said something so laughable that a Sabbath gasbag from the mainstream media, well, laughed at him.

No, it wasn’t the charge that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction.  Not Ron Paul’s bigoted newsletters, or Newt Gingrich’s family-values-except-for-me platform, or Mitt Romney’s attacks on what is essentially his own health care program.

No.  The media laughed because Newt Gingrich, having previously said that Mitt Romney had lied, agreed that Mitt Romney was a liar.  It was the shock of someone going off-script.

Here’s Newt Gingrich quoted on ABC yesterday: “[Romney] set the tone of the campaign … by going after me negatively and dishonestly.”

Now that’s the proper way for a candidate to call a fellow candidate a liar.  But CBS “reporter” Norah O’Donnell knew the script for American presidential campaign “interviews.”  O’Donnell knew that she was to ask whether Gingrich would call Romney a liar, and that Gingrich would not answer, instead pointing out some of Romney’s lies.  Following the script, O’Donnell gamely asked the following ‘question:’ “You said of Mitt Romney, ‘somebody who will lie to you to be President will lie to you when they are President.  I have to ask you, are you calling Mitt Romney a liar?”

Before we go back to the conversation, let’s pause and ponder this.  Someone who goes after a competitor for running ads that are “negative” and “dishonest” is saying they are lying.  Politicians are always suggesting that their competitors’ negative ads are lying.  I really can’t recall a campaign in which politicians haven’t generally said things like “I think that’s disingenuous” or “that’s just not true.”  True, the GOP has ramped it up, what with their people shouting “You lie!” (boy) at shindigs like the State of the Union.

I’d go so far as to suggest, based just on my conversations with people here in California, that some people think many politicians lie pretty often, about a wide variety of things.  Perhaps even you have suspected that some politician somewhere might be a liar.  I confess the thought has crossed my mind.

So, back to CBS. Newt Gingrich had just suggested that Mitt Romney was lying about his negative ads.  The CBS reporter read him his statement saying as much, and asked if he were calling Mitt Romney a liar.  Now, presumably, O’Donnell understood English enough to realize that Newt Gingrich had, in fact, called Mitt Romney a liar.  But, being a well-trained “reporter”, er, spokesmodel, she was aware that according to the script Gingrich would turn the conversation back to Romney’s lies, talking about his campaign ads.

Gingrich tossed away the script.  Asked, “Are you calling Mitt Romney a liar?” Gingrich said something that, for a moment, was the pure, simple, unvarnished truth.  He said “Yes.”

Back on the reporters’ side of the split-screen, we observe a moment of shocked silence.  O’Donnell says, in a tone of disbelief, “You’re calling Mitt Romney a liar?”  Then, in a petulant whine, “why are you calling him a liar?”

Gingrich responds with about a minute of, as far as I can tell, straightforward enough facts establishing that Romney, like perhaps every politician ever to be born, has said untruthful things; that is, that he’s a liar.  CBS has a gasbag on hand for those who want more gravitas than O’Donnell can deliver, and Bob Schieffer rises from his slumber to ask if Gingrich could support Romney if Romney won the nomination.  When Gingrich says, “yes,” Schieffer gets a tiny smile on his face.  That grows to shaking-head-laughter as Schieffer points out that Gingrich is saying he’d vote for a liar before he’d vote for Obama.

Gingrich, for all I can’t stand him, was speaking truth to power.  To his credit, here are his words: “Which part of what I said to you is false?  Why is it that if I’m candid in person and I wanted to be honest in person, that’s shocking?  If his PAC buys millions of dollars of attack ads to say things that are false that’s somehow part of the way Washington plays the game?  Isn’t that exactly what’s sick about this country right now?  Isn’t that what the American people are tired of?”

(Yes, Mr. Gingrich.  We’d like the press to call liars on their lies.  That would be a treat.)

More shocked petulance from O’Donnell.  This man is staying off script!  You can see the “reporters” listening to their earpieces.  Wow!  An exclusive!  Big news!

Gingrich calls Schieffer a “professional reporter,” tells Schieffer he can check for himself, and outlines the various ways in which Romney has been lying.  So Schieffer agrees, right?  No?  Schieffer disagrees?  No, not that either.  Give it a moment’s thought, and you can guess what’s on the script.  That’s right, the segment’s time is just about up.  ”Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker,” Schieffer starts.  But he can’t resist slyly thanking Gingrich for coming on and (changed tone) “answering the questions.”

And then it’s time for some ads, to tell us how much better our lives are because of the efforts of one of CBS’ corporate sponsors.

I could never vote for Gingrich, and I realize that all he’s doing is twisting a knife into a fellow Republican by accusing him of nothing more than what Gingrich and just about every other politician alive is guilty of.  But, for just a minute or so, I could hear truth on network television.  No wonder the spokesmodel was offended.  No wonder Schieffer was amused.

The United States supposedly cherishes freedom of the press.  Indeed,in some hypothetical country, a free press is capable of rooting out corruption and exposing lies from the powerful.  But in our country in recent years, the professional press is no less captured by the corporations than the government.  We are fed scripted infotainment as news.

No, I’m not some conspiracy theorist who thinks people like O’Donnell and Schieffer are told what to say.  But I am able to see that the mainstream media no longer shows any inclination to really explore policy alternatives, examine things that have worked or failed in other countries, look at serious approaches to problems.  The media is interested in the horse race, and in political strategy.  The campaign, for the media, is inexpensive entertainment that will bring in an audience.  The last thing anyone in the professional press wants to do is lose access to a candidate by actually challenging them.

It’s rare these days for things to go off script.  When they do, as with the Gingrich interview, it’s an opportunity to see exactly how worthless the mainstream media has become.  Imagine, for example, if Schieffer had chosen to acknowledge the truth of what Gingrich was saying, and asked Gingrich if he’d ever lied himself, perhaps in a campaign.  A reporter interested in such things would surely have a book-sized list of Gingrich’s lies to fall back upon.  Imagine if O’Donnell had asked Gingrich whether lying was necessary in today’s campaigns.  Gingrich was already off-script, bent more on a mission of destruction than on any campaign.  Who knows what he might have said?  Maybe the honesty would have continued.

Mitch Trachtenberg os a software developer and freelance writer living in the village of Trinidad in Humboldt County. He can be reached at mitchtrachtenberg.com.

11 Responses to “The Emperor is Naked! A Politician Has Lied!”

  1. Kristan says:

    Interesting observations. Nice article.

  2. Rose says:

    I think the honesty would have continued.

  3. Rose says:

    Did you get a chance to watch the two debates with Gingrich one on one with Herman Cain and Jon Huntsman respectively? You might be surprised at the quality of the discussions, and the genuine dialogue that took place.

  4. Mitch says:

    Thanks, Kristan.

    Rose, I happened to see this exchange because when Gingrich called Romney a liar, it flashed to the top of sites like the Huffington Post and Talking Points Memo.

    I haven’t watched the Republican debates because the Republicans are not offering a candidate I would consider voting for. I don’t own a TV (fact, not boast) so my TV is from the internet.

  5. skippy says:

    Nice article and commentary. Helping put this exchange into the context that Mitch describes, the CBS video clip is here, about 3 minutes in:
    http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-500202_162-57351153/gingrich-mitt-romney-is-a-liar/

  6. Mike says:

    Want honesty?

    Check this out.

    1/06/12
    “What if China did in the Gulf of Mexico what we did in the Persian Gulf?”
    -Ron Paul, Durham, NH

  7. Brain says:

    How come nobody has mention Obama`s lies about closing Guantamano,Cuba

    and his signing the arrest without charges law into effect. That is 10 times worse than silly name calling by Repubs. Get real and do honest reporting, or nobody will take you serious.

    • Mitch says:

      Brain,

      Whoever you think is “not mentioning” Obama’s failed promise to close down Guantanamo is doing a dismal job.

      I just typed “obama promise close guantanamo” into Google, went to the sidebar on the right, and clicked “News,” then “Past 24 hours.”

      The first entry comes back “Retired Generals and Admirals Urge Obama to Fulfill Guantanamo Promise”? and connects to 212 similar newspaper articles.

      The second entry is a New York Times editorial entitled “Congress Should Close Guantánamo:”?
      New York Times – 16 hours ago
      From its inception, Guantánamo was intended to be a legal black hole, … the president must step up and keep his promise to close Guantánamo, …

      • Hammie says:

        Very much like Bush/Cheney saying the war in Iraq was over and then spent nearly a trillion taxpayers dollars continuing the war. Other than corporations like Haliburton who benefited? The thousands of American soldiers who returned with missing legs, arms, eyes and severe head trauma. And of course the persons who did benefit would be, Bush and Cheney and Rumsfeld, C. Rice, John Snow, Colin Powell, Robert Gates, Carl Rove and Tom Ridge. Many would call it blood money. I call it treasonous money.

  8. skippy says:

    Brain, there are many important subjects to cover. Everyone writes about they’re interested in, passionate about, and sometimes, what’s important to them. It’s a work in progress here, a labor of love, and our strength, I believe, is in our partnership. Given that, if you or others would like to pen an article for consideration of what’s important, what we honestly need to know, then I’d like to encourage you giving it a try. Seriously, I really do. You and others have much to offer, say, and report.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks


Leave a Reply

Primary Election 2012

Vagabond Journalist

RSS Progressive Review

  • Meanwhile, furthermore & on the other hand
    Chuck Brown and his friend, Eva Cassidy The curse of Camelot A psalm of baseball How to quickly peel a potato TED caves after censoring talk on income inequality Bill Cosby's wonderful description of learning how to play drums, inlcuding freezing up behind Sonny Stitt Some car makers now creating electric bikes Documentary on the UAW leaders, the Reuthe […]
  • Passings: Chuck Brown and his friend
    Reading some of the stories on the recently passed DC go go god, Chuck Brown, we came across the fact that he had been taken by the work of a another singer, the young Eva Cassidy. Although separated in age by more than 25 years , the two produced memorable sounds on a 1992 album, The Other Side. Cassidy , with her skill and ability to sing a broad variety o […]
  • Stats: The NYC police war on young blacks and latinos
    - In Brownsville, Brooklyn In 2009, 93 Out Of Every 100 Residents Were Stopped By The NYPD- - More Young Black Men Were Stopped By The NYPD In 2011 Than There Are Young Black Men in New York City - NYPD Will Stop You For 'Inappropriate Attire Off Season' Also, for visible bulges in your pocket. And, in 51.3 percent of the stops in 2011, cops cited […]
  • Massive student protest in Montreal
    Common Dreams - Thousands of student protesters flooded the streets in Montreal after Quebec Premier Jean Charest announced a proposal for a new 'emergency law' in a bid to end the ongoing 14 week old student uprising and strike. The proposed legislation would halt the spring semester, push up the summer holidays, and restart classes in August. The […]
  • The meaning of the growth in minority births
    Pew Research Center - The nation’s racial and ethnic minority groups—especially Hispanics—are growing more rapidly than the non-Hispanic white population, fueled by both immigration and births. This trend has been taking place for decades, and one result is the Census Bureau’s announcement that non-Hispanic whites now account for a minority of births in the […]
  • Word: A Psalm of baseball
     Mark Thompson Baseball provideth me green pastures. It endureth no storms. It preserveth my youth. It accepteth my failure as average. It keepeth me in order. Baseball alloweth me chance after chance, despite my errors. It forgiveth my stealing. It encourageth my sacrifices. Yea, though I have taken all I can, I am able to walk. It alloweth me to lead. It s […]
  • After Chicago: Bilderberg
    David Swanson, War Is a Crime - From May 31 to June 3, at the Westfields Marriott Washington Dulles Hotel, in Chantilly, Va., the Bilderberg Group is expected to gather behind closed doors. This exclusive club will rent the entire hotel, encircle it with armed guards, and keep everyone far away, including the media -- except for those special members of the […]
  • Why you don't have to listen to Mitt Romney about capitalism
    One of the alternatives to robber baron capitalism is the cooperative. It gets little attention from the media or politicians, but this doesn't mean it doesn't already have a big impact on our economy. This from the Neighboring Food Co-op Association: The NFCA include 30 food co-ops and start-up initiatives across Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticu […]
  • Well, at least he's still a Christian because he's not gay
    Smoking Gun - An Indiana pastor is facing a voyeurism charge for allegedly placing hidden cameras disguised as air fresheners in the women’s bathroom of the Lafayette church he had headed for the last decade. Robert Lyzenga, 55, was arrested last week by the Tippecanoe County Police Department on the felony count. He was freed from custody after posting $500 […]
  • Obama & Duncan reviving the pauper schools that public education got rid of
    Paul Thomas, Truthout- [A report] from the Schott Foundation for Public Education [states]/; "This report will show that evidence of blatant disparities amount to apartheid-like separations that have been accepted in New York for far too long." The Schott study focuses on New York City, but the patterns exposed in the report are typical across the […]
  • US cutting nuke plant drills, test evacuations
    _______________________________________________________ […]
  • The curse of Camelot
    1963 - John F Kennedy assassinated 1964 - Plane carrying Teddy Kennedy crashes, killing aide and pilot and badly injuring Kennedy 1968 - Robert Kennedy assassinated 1969 - Teddy Kennedy drives his car off a bridge in Massachusetts, killing his passenger Mary J Kopechne 1984 - David Kennedy, son of RFK, dies of a drug overdoes in a Florida hotel room 1997 - M […]
  • Israel's apartheid not limited to Palestinians
    Haaretz - Israel's Interior Minister Eli Yishai said on Wednesday that most of the migrants from Africa are engaged in criminal actions and should be placed in detention facilities. Yishai said that Israel is willing to provide financial assistance for migrants to leave._______________________________________________________ […]
  • Orwellandia: British police to steal data from people's cellphones
    Computer World UK - The Metropolitan Police has rolled out a mobile device data extraction system to allow officers to extract data "within minutes" from suspects' phones while they are in custody. Ostensibly, the system has been deployed to target phones that are suspected of having actually been used in criminal activity, although data priva […]
  • Meanwhile, furthermore & on the other hand
    Gary Johnson polls 7% in New Hampshire, 6% in North Carolina, 15% in New Mexico, and 8% in Montana USA Today investigation raises more questions about DC test scores New documantary film on the BP disaster Occupy directory_______________________________________________________ […]
Stop CISPA