Categorized | Politics

Who Bombed Judi Bari?

Car-Bombed Activist Can View Evidence

 

By JONNY BONNER
Courthouse News Service

 

The FBI must hand over evidence tied to a decades-old car bombing in the Bay Area in which two Earth First activists were injured, a federal judge ruled.

On May 24, 1990, a pipe bomb wrapped with nails exploded under the Subaru wagon of environmentalist Judi Bari in Oakland, California. Bari and a fellow activist, Darryl Cherney, were seriously injured in the blast.

The pair had been traveling to college campuses, rallying against the logging of old-growth redwood.

In a federal lawsuit, Bari and Cherney said the Oakland Police Department and FBI framed them, and that the FBI withheld evidence crucial to solving the bombing.

Though Bari died of breast cancer in 1997, a jury ruled in favor of her and Cherney five years later. The parties then spent two years in protracted settlement negotiations.

Bari’s estate and Cherney were awarded $4.4 million in damages, but the FBI failed to release a host of evidence related to the bombing, claiming the evidence was “contraband.”

The withheld evidence includes “the fragments of the device which exploded in Bari’s car, a partially-exploded pipe bomb that was found at a Louisiana Pacific lumber mill in Cloverdale, California.; a hand-lettered sign found near the Cloverdale device reading ‘LP screws mill workers’; a fingerprint obtained from the sign; an analysis of the fingerprint; and a letter to the Santa Rosa Press Democrat newspaper, known as the ‘Lord’s Avenger’ letter, by an individual claiming responsibility for the Cloverdale device and the bombing of Bari’s car,” according to the court.

Cherney objected to the destruction of the evidence, which the FBI was obligated to announce, in 2010, and asked that it be sent to an independent forensic lab for testing.

The government objected to a declaration by attorney James Wheaton that Cherney used to support his motion. Wheaton’s declaration addressed the understanding of the parties at the time of the settlement agreement regarding the disposition of the evidence.

A year later, U.S. Magistrate Judge James Larson upheld Cherney’s objection and Wheaton’s declaration.

U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken affirmed the magistrate’s order.

Having considered all of the papers filed by the parties, the court grants the United States’ motion for de novo review, denies Cherney’s renewed motion to strike, overrules the United States’ objection to the magistrate judge’s order, and grants Cherney’s request for action and motion to implement,” according to the opinion dated Saturday. “The court affirms Magistrate Judge Larson’s order.”

Cherney must propose a test for the evidence, and the United States has 14 days to object to that plan.

Cherney recently released a documentary, “ “Who Bombed Judi Bari?” chronicling the events.

The 14-page court document and order by United States District Judge Claudia Wilken of March 31, 2012, can be found here.

 

This article was reprinted by permission from the Courthouse News Service and forwarded to the Humboldt Sentinel by Skippy Massey. Photographs courtesy of the Humboldt Sentinel.

* * * * * * * * *

Additional articles can be found in the Los Angeles Times’ “Judge Orders Testing of Evidence in Judi Bari Bombing” by Dean Kuipers and the San Francisco Chronicle’s ”Earth First Bomb Evidence Won’t be Destroyed” by Bob Egelko.

Articles and reader comments by the local Humboldt Herald regarding the Judi Bari car bombing can be found here, here, and here.

Leave a Reply

HumSentinel on Twitter

RSS Progressive Review

  • Furthermore. . .
    Nine of the ten cities where people feel least safe walking at night are in the south or in California 25 greenest cities Global nonviolent action database […]
  • Today in history
    Today in history 1912 -- Titanic sinks at 2:20am. Harry Elkins Widener goes down clutching his 1598 edition of Bacon's Essays. Most Americans these days think it is just a movie.  1967 -- US: First mass burning of draft cards as 400,000 march in New York City & 80,000 in San Francisco opposing the Vietnam War. Daily Bleed […]
  • Morning Line: Of hate crimes and traitors
    Sam Smith - The recent killings in Kansas City has revived talk of hate crimes. The problem with having a category of hate crimes is that there is no constitutional prohibition against hating, rotten as it may be. In fact, the right to be wrong is one of the most basic concepts behind our constitution. If you do something illegal, you are to be caught and pu […]
  • Studies: America is an oligarchy, not a democracy
    Gawker - A new study by researchers from Princeton and Northwestern Universities finds that America's government policies reflect the wishes of the rich and of powerful interest groups, rather than the wishes of the majority of citizens.The researchers examined close to 1,800 U.S. policy changes in the years between 1981 and 2002; then, they compared th […]
  • Some ideas we don't even talk about
    Alternet - Venezuela has increased its maternity leave to 6.5 months. In addition, Venezuela pays full-time mothers a pension. This 2012 labor law also outlawed outsourcing, and made it difficult to fire people.Brazil is another Latin American country that has perks for workers. Along with Lithuania, Brazil offers the most paid vacation days in the world: 41 […]
  • Colleges and universities in serious financial trouble
    Zero Hedge - Soaring student debt, competition from online programs and poor job prospects for graduates are shrinking the applicant pools for many universities and, as Bloomberg reports, the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities warns "there will clearly be some institutions that won’t make it...through these difficult steps. […]
  • Stats: America's prisons
    Policy Mic The United States has 5% of the world's population, but 25% of the world's prisoners.The total incarcerated population in the U.S. is 2.4 million — a 500% increase over the past 30 years. One in 28 American children has a parent behind bars.  Currently, 65 million Americans have a criminal record.There are more people behind bars today f […]
  • Pocket paradigms
    Journalism has never been the art of the ideal. Its basic problem is that it attempts to perpetrate the truth, relying for financial support advertisers who have little interest in the pursuit of this goal. It's a bit like a priest being supported by the proceeds of a whorehouse. .- Sam Smith […]
  • Word
    The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum - even encourage the more critical and dissident views. That gives people the sense that there's free thinking going on, while all the time the presuppositions of the system are being reinforced by […]
  • Furthermore. . .
    Meanwhile. . . Trade workers unions and coops: the story so far Sears is dying People participating in the food stamp program outnumbered the women who worked full-time, year-round in the United States in 2012, according to data from the Department of Agriculture and the Census Bureau. In the Mad Men era college tuition averaged $478, but a computer cost $4. […]
  • One reason Comcast is getting away with seizing our airwaves
    The phrase anti-trust is disappearing from our discourseUse of the phrase anti-trust in books 1800 to present […]
  • Rare senator who's not afraid to challenge the Comcast disaster
    The Hill - Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) said that Comcast's plans to purchase Time Warner Cable would harm competition and raise prices in cable television and broadband internet.Franken, one of Capitol Hill's most vocal opponents of the merger, did not mince words in describing his opposition to CNN's Brian Stelter."This is the No. 1 cable […]
  • Hil Clin acted as Boeing marketer while Secretary of State
    Washington Post - On a trip to Moscow early in her tenure as secretary of state, Hillary Rodham Clinton played the role of international saleswoman, pressing Russian government officials to sign a multibillion-dollar deal to buy dozens of aircraft from Boeing.A month later, Clinton was in China, where she jubilantly announced that the aerospace giant would b […]
  • Federal judge rules Ohio gay marriage ban unconstitutional
    Buzz Feed - U.S. District Court Judge Timothy Black  ruled that Ohio’s ban on recognizing the out-of-state marriages of same-sex couples is unconstitutional — a move he announced in court earlier this month that he would be taking.“The record before the Court … is staggeringly devoid of any legitimate justification for the State’s ongoing arbitrary discrimin […]
  • Where to put bike lanes
    538 - Bike lanes don’t cause a lot more congestion if you put them on the right streets. If you cut down the size of streets that are already near capacity, you’ll create severe congestion. But if you start with roads that are well under capacity, you’ll only increase the congestion a little bit. And it may not even be noticeable. Slimming down these roads t […]