Categorized | National, State

Woman Sues FDA and DHSS For Right To Inseminate Self

Whose body and procreative choice is it, anyway?

 

Staff Report
Humboldt Sentinel

We’re surprised the issue hasn’t reached the courts long before this lawsuit was filed on July 2.  Artificial insemination, done outside of intercourse, a clinic, or laboratory, is inherently illegal it turns out, and punishable by fines and jail time.

We surmise the issue could reach all the way to the Supreme Court.

Jonny Bonner of the Courthouse News Service tells us the details below.

 

Free the Sperm!

By Jonny Bonner
Courthouse News Service

 

OAKLAND, Calif. (CN) – A woman demands the right to be artificially inseminated by a willing donor, without paying and “without a medical intermediary, such as a semen bank or medical professional,” in a complaint filed against the federal government.

Jane Doe sued the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the Department of Health and Human Services, in Federal Court.

“The FDA prohibits private individuals from donating semen for artificial insemination on an uncompensated basis unless these individuals comply with a panoply of costly and burdensome regulatory requirements,” the complaint states.  ”These requirements apply even if a man donates semen directly to a woman he considers to be his intimate partner.  In doing so, it violates the rights of the plaintiff, other similarly situated women, and men from whom they seek freely donated gametes.”

The complaint continues:  “These FDA regulations are unconstitutional to the extent that they operate to regulate the noncommercial and sexually intimate choices and activity protected by the rights to privacy, bodily integrity and autonomy, liberty, life, due process, and equal protection guaranteed by the First, Fifth, Ninth, and Tenth Amendments to the United States Constitution.”

Doe claims she is “a woman in a committed, long-term, monogamous relationship with her female partner.  Ms. Doe does not have sexual intercourse with male partners.”  She wants to become pregnant, and “prefers to conceive via intracervical insemination of fresh donor sperm.”

For her own good and that of her child, she “has decided to become pregnant using fresh semen provided by an individual known to her,” so her child can “develop a relationship with his or her father if he or she wishes to do so.”  She claims she “extensively reviewed substantial medical information about this individual and his personal and medical history,” and he agreed to provide the sperm, “which he did, uncompensated, and on a mutually agreed upon date in a mutually agreed upon manner.”

Doe says she “did in fact inseminate herself with this individual’s donated fresh semen and became pregnant.  Unfortunately, the pregnancy was not carried to term.”  She says she was going to try it again, “barring doctor’s orders to the contrary.”

But Doe says the FDA prohibits it, unless she uses “a medical intermediary, such as a medical professional or a semen bank.”  She says these methods restrict her choice of donors, who are “of often anonymous,” and the procedures “very expensive.”

Doe says she “does not want to be forced to engage in sexual intercourse with a male partner to conceive a child, even though such a male partner would not be subject to FDA-required screening and testing, and other FDA-mandated donor-eligibility requirements.”

Nor does she want to use FDA-approved semen, which “is typically cryogenically quarantined for a six-month period.”

Doe wants to perform the procedure herself, via syringe.  She claims FDA regulations restrict the intimate, personal choices available to her and similarly situated women, or “would require Ms. Doe and other similarly situated women to engage in heterosexual intercourse, which would be unconscionable for Ms. Doe on the grounds that she is a lesbian who only engages in sexual intercourse with women.”

She objects, particularly, to the Public Health Service Act, of 1944, and the FDA’s implementing regulations that control “human cells, tissues, and tissue-based products.”  Violation of regulations “is a strict-liability crime that is punishable by imprisonment for up to one year and a fine of up to $1,000,” the complaint states.

Doe, of Oakland, calls the FDA’s regulations “unconstitutional,” and says they “directly prohibit her chosen method of procreation.”

“FDA regulations applying to uncompensated donations of semen by private individuals directly to other private individuals deprive Ms. Doe of access to the reproductive method of her choice and burden her procreative liberty,” the complaint states.

Doe also objects to “the sudden enforcement against private, uncompensated semen donors,” which she says began in November 2010.  On Nov. 1 that year, she says, the FDA’s Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research issued an order to a California man, Trent C. Arsenault, “an individual who donated semen privately and without compensation to women seeking to become pregnant via ICI (intracervical insemination).”

This was despite the fact that Arsenault subjects himself to regular medical tests, posts the results on a publicly available website, and “is personally known to all women to whom he donates semen and has entered into agreements with them regarding mutually agreed-upon obligations,” Doe says in her complaint.

The FDA Order to Arsenault stated: “FDA regulatory requirements do not vary based on whether a sperm donation is free of charge.  FDA regulates any establishment that performs any of these manufacturing steps: recovery, processing, storage, labeling, packaging, distribution, or screening of sperm,” according to Doe’s complaint.

Neither Arsenault, apparently, nor Doe’s chosen donor, complies with those FDA regulations.

Doe says she has a “fundamental right to procreative choice,” which the defendants are violating.  She claims they also violate her, and women’s and donors’, rights to equal protection, and that the rules violate the Commerce Clause.  She wants the rules enjoined as unconstitutional.  She also seeks attorney’s fees and costs.

Named as defendants are FDA Commissioner Margaret Hamburg and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius.  Although the complaint mentions similarly situated women several times, it never explicitly states that Doe filed it as a class action suit.

Doe is represented by Amber Abbasi, with Cause of Action, of Washington, D.C.  You can view her lawsuit here.

Article courtesy of Jonny Bonner and the Courthouse News Service.

* * * * * * * * * *

Hands off my food– and my body, FDA.  Or do we just keep it in the closet?  Don’t rain on our rainbow.

The times they are a-changin’.  We wonder how the pro-life crowd feel about this matter–or those wishing less governmental regulation in business. 

(Posted by Skippy Massey)

One Response to “Woman Sues FDA and DHSS For Right To Inseminate Self”

  1. Marc says:

    Maybe the FDA wants everyone to use their “special” sperm… I’d get paranoid if I was subject to this…

Trackbacks/Pingbacks


Leave a Reply

HumSentinel on Twitter

RSS Progressive Review

  • Great moments in school discipline: camper punished for having Swiss Army knife
    Daily Caller - A fifth-grader in Cupertino, California was suspended and threatened with expulsion for bringing a small Swiss Army knife on a school-sponsored, science-oriented camping trip. In early April, Braden Bandermann’s class set off on Garden Gate Elementary School’s annual, week-long pilgrimage for fifth-graders to the Marin Headlands, just north of […]
  • Shop Talk: It's lead, not lede
    Sam Smith - One of the true joys in life is to discover that something you thought was true or false but couldn't prove turns out to be what you thought. For example, I could never understand why journalists were starting to spell lead as lede.Journalist Howard Owens has come to my rescue. Howard Owens - Early in my career somebody I obviously respected […]
  • Amphibian creatures disappearing faster than thought
    Baltimore Sun -  A new study finds frogs, toads and salamanders disappearing at an alarming rate across the United States.In what they say is the first analysis of its kind, scientists with the U.S. Geological Survey and a couple of universities report that declines in environmentally sensitive amphibians are more widespread and more severe than previously t […]
  • Judge sentenced to 28 years for kickbacks for sending kids to private prisons
    Black News - Mark Ciavarella Jr, a 61-year old former judge in Pennsylvania, has been sentenced to nearly 30 years in prison for literally selling young juveniles for cash. He was convicted of accepting money in exchange for incarcerating thousands of adults and children into a prison facility owned by a developer who was paying him under the table. The kick […]
  • Untitled
    _______________________________________________________ […]
  • Meanwhile, furthermore & on the other hand
    33% work more than 40 hours a week Jews & secularists are best tippers   The payoff for being on a reality show Apple has $30 billion tax free in Irish accounts 18 big corporations that keep huge amounts of money overseas Stereotype buster of the day Quotes A classic is something that everybody wants to have read and nobody wants to read. - Mark Twain Po […]
  • Rebuilding America: Concentrate on specific issues
     Another in our series on Rebuilding America Sam Smith - I learned this secret many years ago when I first became involved in activism. The issue then was an unwanted fare increase by DC Transit. The organizer was the heavily black and young Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee but the participants came from all over including 100,000 riders who stayed […]
  • The real Hillary Clinton: Whether or not to indict
    On April 27, 1998, deputy independent counsel Hickman Ewing met with his prosecutors to decide on whether to indict Hillary Clinton. Here's what happened as reported by Sue Schmidt and Michael Weisskopf in their book, "Truth at Any Cost:" "[Ewing] paced the room for more than three hours, recalling facts from memory in his distinctive Mem […]
  • State Department names Israel lobbyist as special envoy on anti-semitism
    MJ Rosenberg, Mondoweiss - The new State Department Envoy on anti-Semitism is former AIPAC lobbyist Ira Forman, a guy whose entire career has been dedicated to advancing the policies of the Israeli government, at AIPAC and then as head of the National Jewish Democratic Council, where he worked to ensure that Democrats were more hawkish on Israel than Republi […]
  • FBI spied on leading anti-war online news journal
    Economic Policy Journal - The editors of Antiwar.com have known for some time that the FBI has had an eye on them. Naturally enough, they used the Freedom of Information Act to request bureau’s files on them and their organization—but the FBI hasn’t been forthcoming. Now the ACLU has filed suit to force the bureau to divulge the extent of its snooping on ant […]
  • Police blotter
    Daily Mail, UK - A market trader who ran an illegal lending racket from his fruit and veg stall has avoided jail after a court heard his interest rates were over 100 times lower than licensed payday loan firms.Stephen Fossey, 45, used his pitch at Bacup market, Lancashire, to give credit to up to 180 customers over a four-year period.He typically charged bet […]
  • More on federal governrment telephone spying
    Gregory J. Millman, Wall Street Journal - U.S.-based telecoms companies routinely supply hundreds of thousands of records annually in response to subpoenas, which might come from federal, state or local government law enforcement bodies, and any entity with subpoena power can obtain phone records without notice being given to the target of an investigation, […]
  • Green Shadow Cabinet: A dehumanized society and emotional suffering
    Clinical psychologist Bruce Levine is assistant secretary for health in the Green Party shadow cabinet Bruce Levine - Big Pharma corruption of mental health institutions has meant an ever-increasing focus on our biochemistry. We are diverted from the reality that many emotional problems are not caused by biochemical or genetic defects but are often natural h […]
  • Morning Line: If you have to ask, there's a problem
    Sam Smith - There has been a lot of talk - here and elsewhere - about various Obama violations of the Constitution and, of course, the lawyers are having a field day about it all. But here's something that gets missed. People who support and practice constitutional principles don't need lawyers to argue their case. You just know it. Virtue has  a c […]
  • Death notice
    Legacy -  HOLCOMB, Robert (Bob) Died a couple of days ago which wasn't exactly unexpected as he had been in poopy health for years. While he never complained much, those that knew him were aware that he suffered several heart attacks and had quadruple bypass open heart surgery before age 40, and it kinda went downhill from there. ... In addition to his […]