Categorized | National, Politics

GOP Rape Bill Sparks Outrage

 

Proposed New Mexico Law Would Now Prosecute Abortion Providers Instead of Rape Victims

 

Skippy Massey
Humboldt Sentinel

 

Santa Fe, New MexicoA Republican state lawmaker in
New Mexico proposed a law last week that would send a
woman to prison for three years on a felony if she had an
abortion after being raped– for “tampering with evidence.”

State Rep. Cathrynn Brown, R-Carlsbad, introduced H.B. 206. It states:

Tampering with evidence shall include procuring or facilitating an abortion, or compelling or coercing another to obtain an abortion, of a fetus that is the result of criminal sexual penetration or incest with the intent to destroy evidence of the crime.”

The physician and health care professionals who perform the abortion could be charged criminally as well with a felony.

Cathrynn BrownBrown says it’s all a misunderstanding.  She said her intent was not to go after rape and incest victims, but to prosecute rapists and incest perpetrators who coerce women into having abortions.  She said the mistake occurred during the drafting of the bill, and she’s working on a substitute to make it clear the proposal wouldn’t apply to the victims.

Brown is a Carlsbad lawyer serving her second term in the New Mexico House since 2010.  She’s a past GOP chairwoman and has been on the board of Right to Life of Carlsbad, an outspoken
anti-abortion group.

 

Controversy and Outcry

Nine New Mexico House Republicans, all women, signed on as co-sponsors.  The bill quickly caught the eye of ABC News, The Huffington Post, Slate, Courthouse News, and Salon.com.

too farNew Mexico’s state Democratic Party, the American Civil Liberties Union, Planned Parenthood, and House Democrats all blasted the bill.

The first to publicize Brown’s bill was the liberal PAC Progress Now New Mexico.  “In addition to being blatantly unconstitutional, the bill turns victims of rape and incest into felons and forces them to become incubators of evidence for the state,” said Pat Davis, the group’s executive director.

Democratic Party Chairman Javier Gonzales called the legislation “atrocious” and demanded, “The war on women in America has to stop. No woman should ever be forced to carry a child for evidence, plain and simple.”

New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez, a Republican, moved to distance herself from HB 206.  Responding to a request for a comment, her spokesperson said Martinez, as a career prosecutor, “would never support a bill that re-victimized rape survivors.”

On the national level, Democrats have decried a GOP “war on women” and cited outlandish statements about rape by Republican candidates to bolster that claim.  Some Republicans have said that such missteps by Missouri Senate candidate Todd Akin and Indiana Senate contender Richard Mourdock cost the party U.S. Senate seats in those states.

 

Revising a Poorly Written Bill

new mexicoIn an interview last Thursday, Brown explained her intention, saying, “I’ve been talking to my constituents in Carlsbad and with law enforcement people, and they say we’re not doing enough to protect women and children.”

Her intent, she said, is to “go after perpetrators of incest and criminal sexual penetration who cover up their crime by forcing girls and women to get abortions.”  Prosecuting rape or incest victims was never the goal of the bill, Brown stressed, adding, “It’s the guy who does the sex crime.”

Brown revised her original bill Friday to specify that victims can’t be charged.

Brown posted the new version of the bill on her personal website.  In the new version of her bill, she added a sentence saying “In no circumstance shall the mother of the fetus be charged under this subsection.”  The original version of the bill, however, is still posted on the Legislature’s website.

The executive director of the state Democratic Party said Friday that the ‘new’ Brown bill still has problems.

“The bill still makes it a crime to ‘facilitate’ an abortion for a woman who wants one …,” said Scott Forrester in a news release.  “That means doctors, nurses, or anyone else who works at a health care clinic where this is one of the services provided would still be guilty of a felony.”

In another twist, Brown on Friday explained to a news reporter how the poorly written bill came about.  She had asked a bill drafter with the Legislative Council Service whether she should include a sentence about not charging the mother.  But, she said, the drafter told her that it wouldn’t be necessary– and prosecutors would understand that.

Brown has said part of the problem was that the original drafter quit his job before finishing the bill, so it went to another drafter.

peppersAsked about what had happened with drafting Brown’s bill and for permission to look at the file, John Yaeger of the Legislative Council Service said, “… we’re prohibited by law from disclosing the nature or contents of any request from a legislator, which includes any conversations, communications and the file.”

Critics of the proposed bill are questioning whether Cathrynn Brown and the New Mexico Legislature are going too far, overreaching for evidence from rape victims that would normally be obtained in other ways while
criminalizing
abortion health care providers.

* * * * * * * *

4 Responses to “GOP Rape Bill Sparks Outrage”

  1. lawyer salary says:

    Fantastic article. Continue the good work.

    • skippy says:

      Thanks, Lawyer Salary. In years past, the GOP used to have a larger tent in which to invite everyone into. Now they’ve become an exclusive club for fewer and fewer folks as of late. The GOP promises they’re going to do better in their outreach attempts. We wish them the best of luck, after mitigating those divisions fracturing their own party from within and working unselfishly for the common interests of the American people, as they did years ago. The same goes for the Democrats.

  2. @yungkashsk says:

    Interesting blog and post here! Great information and good work, well done!

  3. Lawyer says:

    A neighbor of mine urged me to see your site a month or so back because we like the same issues, and I would like you to know I’m impressed.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks


Leave a Reply

HumSentinel on Twitter

RSS Progressive Review

  • Links: War and peace
    NEWS PeaceWar Torture Veterans   ESSAYS The good thing about war Essays on war Mission creep: the militarizing of America Spooks & spies All war all the time The biggest threast to us: ourselves Why is the military sacred? A speech CSPAN didn't like   GROUPS American Friends Service Committee War is a Crime World Beyond War   MEDIA Anti-War Daniel E […]
  • Links: War and peace
    NEWS Peace War Department Torture Veterans   ESSAYS The good thing about war Essays on war Mission creep: the militarizing of America Spooks & spies All war all the time The biggest threast to us: ourselves Why is the military sacred? A speech CSPAN didn't like   GROUPS American Friends Service Committee War is a Crime World Beyond War   MEDIA Anti- […]
  • Pocket Paradigms
    We can, as those in charge would like, continue to define ourselves primarily by neatly described identities -- either natural or acquired. We can remain interminably and ineffectually absorbed and angry about the particulars of infinite special injustices. Or we can ask what is it that makes our society seem so unfair to so many who are so different? If the […]
  • Word
    If you're not careful the media will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing. -- Malcolm X […]
  • Why we need history
    From 50 uyears of our overstocked archivesSam Smith, 2006 - Now that Frances Fukuyama has rediscovered history, the Nation Magazine's Katrina Vanden Heuvel would like to put it to bed again. In the best tradition of the establishment's view of "civil discourse" - i.e. avoiding the real issues - Vanden Heuvel suggested in the :Washington P […]
  • Links: Transportation
    Transportation news Bike news High speed, high cost, high income rail What roads and rails tell us about class and power […]
  • Jazz break
    GEORGE SHEARING […]
  • What's happening
    Supreme Court clears the way for Texas voter ID lawSome clinical thoughts on EbolaJudge strikes down Arizona’s gay marriage banCops Need a Warrant to Grab Your Cell Tower Data, Florida Court Rules  […]
  • Americans taking fewer vacations
    Vox […]
  • Why America can;t deal with a health crisis
    Sarah Robinson, 2008 - Our every-man-for-himself attitude toward health care is a security threat on a par with unsecured ports. In Canada, people go see the doctor if they’re sick for more than a day or two. It was this easy access to early treatment, along with the much tighter public health matrix that enables doctors to share information quickly, that al […]
  • Pocket paradigms
    We live now with dishonest politics, disinformed and disinforming media, disconnected cultures, disjointed economics, dysfunctional communities and disrespected citizens. To attempt to repair such conditions without a morally conscious politics makes as much sense as trying to revive a body without a heart. This is not romanticism, idealism or naivete, just […]
  • Word
    We [reporters] were perceived as a lower form of life, amoral, half-literate hacks in cheap suits. Thus I was assigned to a Chamber of Commerce meeting in Nashville in the late 1940s and, with other reporters, was given lunch at a card table set up in a hallway to protect the dining room from contamination. -- Richard Harwood […]
  • The immigration myth
    Sam Smith, 2006 - It is taken as a given in the immigration debate that our current system for dealing with the issue has some sort of historical logic. It doesn't. The story of immigration in the U.S. is a mishmash of hospitality and hatred, encouragement and restriction.The Naturalization Act of 1790, for example, said that "any alien, being a fr […]
  • What's happening
    Foreclosure activity across the United States declined to the lowest level since July 2006, as banks reclaimed fewer homesThe number of Americans filing new claims for jobless benefits fell to a 14-year low last week and industrial output rose sharply in September64 countries require some GMO labelling […]
  • Wikileaks releases more anti-constitutional trade deal info
    Common Dreams - WikiLeaks on Thursday released a second updated version of the Trans-Pacific Partnership Intellectual Property Rights chapter, charging that it will hinder affordable access to medicines globally, increase online surveillance, and impinge on civil liberties while benefiting Big Pharma and other corporate interests."Our first impression i […]