Categorized | Media, National

Caught in the Conflict of Gaza

 

It Can Be Done:

Negotiate an End to the Siege

**VIDEO**

 

Joseph A. Palermo
Huffington Post

 

 

The gutless American political class has abdicated its
responsibility for the actions of the Israel Defense Forces.

Few people living in the Middle East or anywhere else make the distinction between the United States and Israel, nor should they with all those weapons stamped “made in the USA.”  It’s supremely foolish to conclude that Israel can never negotiate with Hamas on lifting the siege of Gaza.

The American rhetoric of spreading “freedom” has been a legitimizing argument dating back to the 1898 Spanish-American War when we were “liberating” the Cubans and Filipinos from the yoke of Spanish colonialism.

When the U.S. Senate votes 100 to zero to support whatever the IDF does in Gaza our political “leaders” might not realize it, but they’re undermining the ideological architecture that has allowed them to drive this country into every other war.

United States military interventions have always been accompanied by justifications that emphasize the goal of social uplift for the country under attack.  The U.S. might bomb women and children but we’re there to “help” our allies build schools and clinics or bring “freedom” and “women’s rights” to the dispossessed.  We are told the violence is targeted at those opponents who would sabotage the good progress the U.S. is trying to make in Vietnam or Afghanistan or Iraq.

The discourse around the Israel-Palestine struggle has an antiquated settler state accent to it more akin to the America of the 19th Century when white people were “defending” themselves against the onslaught of Native Americans– whose lands were being annexed.

In the 20th Century, especially since the Second World War, the portrayal of U.S. military action is always sold as being altruistic in nature.  The U.S. engages in wars only reluctantly and for the highest ideals.

The historical context for the Israel-Palestine fight today has changed markedly from what it has been over the past half century.  This is not 1967, or 1973, or 1982.  Today in Iraq, Sunni fanatics dominate large swathes of the country and have already ethnically cleansed the Christians from Mosul after a pretty good run of 1,900 years.

With the breakup of Iraq and Syria, the rise of ISIS and other newly-minted anti-Western groups and the realization that the United States is not going reinvade Iraq nor bomb Iran, the neo-conservative juggernaut as far as U.S. policy goes for now, is effectively finished.

Bibi Netanyahu’s stubborn conviction that Israel can never talk to Hamas fails to take into account the shifting regional and global dynamics.  His viewpoint is just a fearful, right-wing reaction that fails to recognize the shifting contours of history.

Pro-war voices always say that negotiations are impossible.  The white minority rulers of South Africa said it– but Apartheid collapsed.  The East German regime said it– but the Berlin Wall came down. The Protestants in Northern Ireland said it too.

Times change.  And the United States is no longer the superpower it once was.  The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq have depleted our resources and have created a broad based domestic anti-war backlash.

In addition, the nation suffers from historic levels of income and wealth inequality, chronic trade imbalances, mass incarceration, a huge national debt and a Congress with precious little connection to the will of the people.  In short, the U.S. is in no position to allow its surrogates to dictate terms.

During the Vietnam War, New York Senator Robert F. Kennedy tried to explain to his pro-war detractors why he was calling for talks when they claimed the U.S. was “winning.”

“I thought we were at a critical time,” he said. “And before we take the final plunge to even greater escalation, I think we should try negotiation.  If we can’t find the answer to it we can always go back to the war.”

In November 1967, Kennedy questioned the moral appeals that had been made from the earliest days of the U.S. intervention.  He told a panel of Washington journalists on Face the Nation that the US’s “moral position” in the conflict had “changed tremendously.”

“We’re killing South Vietnamese; we’re killing children; we’re killing women; we’re killing innocent people,” Kennedy said.  He had not yet announced his presidential run but his speeches and other public remarks on Vietnam challenged the narrative that had enabled the war in the first place.

Wittingly or not, RFK had shredded the pro-war moral appeals.

Kennedy was also a strong supporter of Israel.  Days before he was murdered at the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles on June 5, 1968, he had appeared at an event in that city wearing a yarmulke and calling for advanced fighter jets to be sent to Israel.

A 24-year-old Palestinian who apparently had been enraged by RFK’s views fired his $30 Iver-Johnson pistol at the Senator shortly after Kennedy won the California Democratic primary.  The Canadian historian, Gil Troy, (an uncritical booster of Israel) has referred to RFK’s assassination as the first act of “Arab terrorism”
on U.S. soil.

So, RFK, who might have become President of the United States, was murdered at the age of 42 ostensibly as an indirect byproduct of the Israel-Palestine conflict.  

Enough is enough.  History cannot be frozen in place. Things have a way of moving along.  Just consider how social media has countered the dominant narrative of the current IDF attack on Gaza and one can see that we now reside in a new world.

There are so many stakeholders, not only in the Middle East but also in Europe and beyond, that would like to see an end to this madness in Gaza. 

The vital thing confronting us today is for the United States to put pressure on Israel to lift the siege of Gaza and seek a viable and realistic political solution.

And if negotiations fail, as RFK said about Vietnam in 1967, “we can always go back to the war.”

The vital thing is to try.

* * * * * * * * * * *

Before earning a Master’s degree and Doctorate in History from Cornell University, Professor Palermo completed Bachelor’s degrees in Sociology and Anthropology from the University of California, Santa Cruz, and a Master’s degree in History from San Jose State University.

His expertise includes the 1980s; political history; presidential politics and war powers; social movements of the 20th century; the 1960s; and the history of American foreign policy. Professor Palermo has also written articles for anthologies on the life of Father Daniel Berrigan, S.J. in The Human Tradition in America Since 1945 and on the Watergate scandal in Watergate and the Resignation of Richard Nixon.

Professor of History at California State University, Sacramento, Professor Palermo’s most recent book is The Eighties. He has also written two other books: In His Own Right: The Political Odyssey of Senator Robert F. Kennedy and Robert F. Kennedy and the Death of American Ideals.

Part of the Iona Brotherhood, we thank Dr. Palermo for sharing his work with our readers here.

 

 

Thank you for making us the best
little blog in Humboldt.

Please share and follow us
on Twitter and Facebook

3 Responses to “Caught in the Conflict of Gaza”

  1. Steve says:

    I wouldn’t count on Sirhan Sirhan’s conviction withstanding historical scrutiny after our Zionist politically biased century is over. I went to high school in Glendale and I swear Sirhan Sirhan was in my English class there yet records show he graduated from a high school in Pasadena next door to Glendale. I’ve always wondered if he was taking an extra English class there. The fellow in our class certainly didn’t strike me then as “terrorist” material. I have a funny connection to this whole business as I met and once looked for marijuana plants in W.L.A. with Kerry Thornley who I met at a coffeehouse near LACC where I was taking classes. He was all about his friendship with Oswald and being under the radar then. A strange coincidence considering my high school contact with someone who sure seemed like Sirhan. That’s the name I remember the teacher calling this student.

    I don’t trust any government reports about these assassinations as our country is under Zionist control of information that may be critical to any investigation of JFK or RFK e.g. the cover up of Jack Rubenstein’s connections to Meyer Lanski and his connections to Israel.

  2. Joe Blow says:

    Too late for a negotiated resolution. The Jews want total capitulation to justify their legitimate existence and the U.S. intends to do every thing it can do to bring that about. Unfortunately, this time the Jews have gone too far and intend to go farther. I may not know much about this life, however, there is one irrefutable, immutable Universal Law I do know about: “You always reap what you sow.” The United States will suffer horrendous consequences for supporting and protecting the Jew in their lawless butchery of innocent people.

  3. Steve says:

    Because I am a spiritually led Christian instead of being a member of any “Christian” organized religion, I can see that historically the Abrahamic religions always produce religious fascists whenever social or political opportunity arises to do so. Each Abrahamic religion has its fascist core: Judaism teaches genocide to obtain land not its own. Pauline Christianity taught Christians to obey without question Roman Empire fascist Caesars then fascist Popes. And of course Muhammad’s purely fascist throwback religion propelling the other two to battle in a repeat of the Crusades, Europeans, Jews this time instead of Christian, trying to own and control the Middle East.

    I wish the rate of information flow were higher than it is as the historical news about the writers of the Bible has not been absorbed by Jewish or Christian or Muslim leaders and their followers. They don’t know that all their Bible beliefs based on Bible events and personages are all fictions, Jewish myths of origin that never happened. Archeology proves this by showing that there was no Hebrew presence in Canaan/Palestine before 700 B.C. making all the early “Hebrews” just characters in stories given phony geneological bases that when examined closely include foreign gods made to act as “Hebrews”, starting with Abraham and Sarah and Hagar, these being Judahs’ ripoff of Brahmin deities, sun god Brahma the Creator, and their Goddesses with river origins Sarasvati, named after the Sarasvati River and whose main tributary the Ghaggar becomes Hagar in the Hebrew makeover. Where on earth would Hebrews learn about Brahmin religion? By the fact that in the 1st millennia BC there existed a thriving Brahmin merchant incense and spice trade with trade routes through the Near East and the Brahmins centered in Yemen in the Kingdom of Sheba which is actually named for the 7th Realm of Shiva which is where the Hebrew word “Shabbat”, the 7th Day, originates. Judaism also picked up the Brahmin racist ideology of “Priests of God” having no social intercourse other than as Masters to other castes labeled inferior human beings. Not having a large populace to produce social classes the Hebrews whittled the inferior castes down to all non-Jews as Gentiles and not worthy of God’s concern. This racist attitude allows Israeli Jews to kill innocent Gentile Arab Palestinians without remorse because to them the Gazans are just animals threatening their peaceful enjoyment of living out a religious lie, the creation of Eretz Yisrael as another example of European racist ideology that produced “Manifest Destiny” genociding Native America and produced the Third Reich ideology and the Socialist World state ideology. Muhammadism produces its own fascist ideology and we get fascist religious Abrahamic wars, again and again.

    I teach Celestial Torah Christianity which is not based on Bible mythologies that cause so much unnecessary social violence in our world.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks


Leave a Reply

HumSentinel on Twitter

RSS Progressive Review

  • A short history of the economic American
    Sam Smith, Shadows of Hope, 1994 - Encomiums to the wonders of market forces fill speeches and media reports. One National Public Radio reporter even went so far as to describe a form of government called market democracy, apparently a blend of the Bill of Rights and the Wall Street Journal editorial page.In fact, most free workers in this country were self- […]
  • Govrnment links
    Project on Government Oversight Government Accountability Project Wikileaks   WHISTLEBLOWERS Thomas Drake Bill Binney Chelsea Manning Project on Gov Oversight Edward Snowden […]
  • Another reason to like whistleblowers
    Guardian, UK - A new study tracking the economic effects of whistleblowers has found that people who come forward to report wrongdoing helped the US government secure $21.27bn more in fines over 35 years.The study, conducted by researchers from Arizona State University, American University, Texas A&M University and University of Iowa, set out to discover […]
  • Reminder to the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge: We won the revolution
    Daily Mail, UK - American journalists have been given a dressing down about how they dress up ahead of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge's royal visit next month.The Duke and Duchess will visit New York City and Washington, DC, for three days, their first official visit to the US in three years.Reporters have been given a strict dress code, reminding th […]
  • Word
    The problem with doing nothing is not knowing when you're finished. - Ben Franklin […]
  • Pocket paradigms
    We tend to discount the importance of unplanned moments because of our fealty to the business school paradigm in which change properly occurs because of a careful strategic plan, an organized vision, procedures, and process. During the past quarter century when such ideas have been in ascendancy, however, America has demonstratively deteriorated as a politic […]
  • Mitch
    From 50 years of our overstocked archivesSam Smith, 1990 - This spring, when homeless activist Mitch Snyder announced he was going to retreat to a monastery for awhile for reflection and renewal, I felt pulled to drop him a note thanking him for his witness, for the good it had done, for the wisdom and encouragmeent it had given others. In the note I quoted […]
  • When was the last time a Mexican cut your pension?
    Sam Smith, 2006 - Those wishing to test the extent of the immigrant problem might want to conduct this quick test:1. Has a Mexican ever fired or laid you off?2. Has the plant you worked for until it was sent overseas been bought by Mexicans or is it still owned by the same people you used to work for?3. Has a Mexican ever cut your pension or health benefits? […]
  • Who's an American citizen?
    1600s Most of various tribes scattered throughout the continent didn't know whether they were Americans as there was no one to tell them 1774 Continental Congress leaves it to each state to decide who shall be a voting citizen 1776 Full citizenship to white male property owners, with six states granting it to all white males whether they had property or […]
  • What's up: Thursday afternoon
    Exit polls found that 62% of Democrats voting said they never attend any sort of religious event. For Republicans the figure was 35%. […]
  • Neil Young starts Starbucks boycott over GMO suit
    Rolling Stone - Neil Young is seeking a new source for his daily latte. The rocker announced on his website this week that he's boycotting Starbucks over the coffee company's involvement in a lawsuit against the state of Vermont's new requirements to label genetically modified ingredients."I used to line up and get my latte everyday, but […]
  • The art of the counter-boycott
    Jesse Walker, Reason - Palermo, the largest city in Sicily, is at the heart of mafia country. In the past, trade association surveys have shown that about 80 percent of the town's shops were paying pizzo. But now more than 900 Sicilian firms, a majority of them in Palermo, are publicly refusing to give money to the mob, thanks to one of the most remarka […]
  • What's up: Thursday morning
    Dissenters within the National Security Agency, led by a senior agency executive, warned in 2009 that the program to secretly collect American phone records wasn't providing enough intelligence to justify the backlash it would cause if revealed, current and former intelligence officials sayThe Green Party of Germany announced that a coalition agreement […]
  • Bank of North Dakota outperforms Wall Street
    Counterpunch - While 49 state treasuries were submerged in red ink after the 2008 financial crash, one state’s bank outperformed all others and actually launched an economy-shifting new industry.  So reports the Wall Street Journal, discussing the Bank of North Dakota and its striking success in the midst of a national financial collapse led by the major ban […]
  • Oaklanders find rank choice voting easy
    East Bay Express - In the weeks before the November 4 election, numerous news stories in the mainstream press focused on whether ranked choice voting was too complicated for Oakland voters to understand. At one point, Governor Jerry Brown, an Oakland resident and a longtime opponent of RCV, called the voting system "complexifying." But results of t […]